The newest storefront on Old Hilliard's Main Street is in a former Chevrolet dealership. A bakery that started in a 400-square-foot market stall moved in. The next big restaurant on the street will put its wine cellar in a bank vault, and it isn't expected to open until early 2028. Main Street is changing building by building, as existing structures get reworked for local tenants. This fall that means three timelines are running at once. Some businesses are open now, one is close, and one is still more than a year of construction away.
If you've been watching storefronts and wondering why things seem to take so long, the buildings explain most of it.
The Garage at 4045 Main
Bakes by Lo opened its first standalone storefront on Sept. 12 at 4045 Main St. The building is the former Ketchum's Garage, which served Old Hilliard for decades as a Chevrolet dealership and later as an auto service center. When the garage closed after its owner retired, Andy Warnock's Westwood Collective bought the property and renovated it rather than tearing it down. The building is now split into two tenant spaces.
The size change tells the story. Owner Laura Young started Bakes by Lo in 2020 in a stall of about 400 square feet inside Center Street Market. The new space is 1,600 square feet: roughly 1,200 of kitchen, plus indoor seating and a small patio. "We were working with two tables at our old space," Young told Columbus Monthly before the opening.
The other half of the garage goes to Cyclical Nature Bicycles, which is moving from 4566 Cemetery Road. The Hilliard Development Corporation gave a combined $70,000 grant for the property's exterior. It covered concrete, paint, artificial turf, lighting, signage, bike racks, landscaping and outdoor furniture. According to the Hilliard Herald, Warnock is a Bakes by Lo customer himself and approached Young about moving once Westwood had bought the building.
Center Street Market Keeps Supplying Main Street
Bakes by Lo got its start through Crooked Can Brewing Company. Its owners saw Young at a farmers market in 2019 and invited her to take a stall when Center Street Market opened in 2020. By 2024 the bakery had outgrown the stall and was sharing a kiosk inside the market with Coffee Connections.
Today both businesses that shared that kiosk have Main Street addresses. Coffee Connections' path was rougher. Owners Sharon and Nate Grenier had to leave their storefront at 4004 Main St. after structural damage to the floor, and their reported last day there was June 27. By early August they had reopened a few doors down as a temporary pop-up in the basement of Cornerstone Christian Fellowship at 4066 Main St. NBC4 reported hours of 7 a.m. to noon, Wednesday through Saturday. The Greniers said they were still weighing longer-term plans, and the church arrangement wasn't final. In September, the city's For the Love of Hilliard festival used 4066 Main as its tote pickup spot.
The market is still adding vendors. Dojo Dumplings opened June 10 inside Center Street Market at 5354 Center St., serving made-to-order dumplings, noodles, bao and rice bowls. Two businesses that once shared a kiosk now sit on Main Street, and the market is filling stalls behind them.
Why It Moves at This Speed
Westwood Collective shows up again and again on the street, and its strategy explains the pace. In a 2022 interview with Columbus Underground, Warnock said the plan was to follow the city's public investments in downtown with private ones. He described a walkable district for residents that mixes reused historic buildings with modest new construction. He was explicit that it would not be a high-rise copy of Bridge Park. At that point Westwood had acquired more than 20 Old Hilliard properties, including the Junction building it shares with Sexton's Pizza and the Legacy Smokehouse building. The count is from 2022. Westwood's current Hilliard portfolio lists Firefly Winery, the Junction, The One9 golf lounge, Westwood Fieldhouse, the Yard and Ketchum's Garage.
Reusing buildings means waiting for each one to come open and then renovating whatever is inside. The former Legacy Smokehouse at 3987 Main St. is the next one in line. Westwood owns the building and says it brokered the lease with Harvest Pizzeria. The June 19 announcement said renovations would begin within weeks and projected a fall opening. This will be Harvest's seventh Central Ohio location. The others are the original German Village shop, opened in 2012, plus the Brewery District, Bexley, Clintonville, Dublin and Granville. As of Oct. 4, Harvest's own locations page still lists Hilliard as "Coming Soon," with no date.
The Bank on the Long Timeline
The longest timeline belongs to the former Chase bank at 4056 Main St. Lira Italian Kitchen is a partnership between Westwood and Around The Clock Hospitality, the group behind The Clocktower Kitchen + Bar in Plain City. NBC4 reports a target opening in the first quarter of 2028. The land deal is expected to close in November, with groundbreaking after that. From today, the start of 2028 is just under 15 months away.
Like the garage, the bank stays standing. The 2,252-square-foot building will be renovated and connected to a new two-story addition. The vault becomes a wine cellar, and the rest of the bank will hold a dining room, a bar and a dedicated pasta room. The addition will house the kitchen, built around a large wood-fired Argentinian-style grill, plus a second-floor mezzanine for private dining. Plans show 140 seats inside and 34 outside. Co-founder Benjamyn Greig explained the choice of cuisine to NBC4:
"I actually grew up probably about a mile and a half from there, from the actual location, and Hilliard has been needing something more upscale for quite some time. And we settled on Italian because we thought we could do that best."
The restaurant anchors a larger project. The full site is about 22,847 square feet across three buildings, including two new three-story buildings with retail and office space below and 11 apartments above. Hilliard's Planning and Zoning Commission approved the site plan 6–0 on July 9. City Council approved the restaurant and upper-floor apartments on Aug. 24. The July minutes list Playa Bowls, Johnson's Ice Cream and a burger-bar concept from Sexton's Pizza as tentative tenants for the smaller commercial spaces. Tentative means none of them is confirmed yet.
Main Street, Building by Building
| Address | What the building was | What's there now or next | Status as of Oct. 4, 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4045 Main St. | Ketchum's Garage, Chevrolet dealership and auto service | Bakes by Lo and Cyclical Nature Bicycles | Bakes by Lo open since Sept. 12; bike shop moving in |
| 4066 Main St. | Cornerstone Christian Fellowship | Coffee Connections pop-up in the basement | Temporary, last reported hours 7 a.m. to noon, Wed–Sat |
| 4004 Main St. | Coffee Connections storefront | Closed after floor damage | Closed since late June |
| 3987 Main St. | Legacy Smokehouse | Harvest Pizzeria | Listed as "Coming Soon," no date |
| 4056 Main St. | Chase bank | Lira Italian Kitchen plus two new mixed-use buildings | Land closing expected November; target opening Q1 2028 |
| 5354 Center St. | Center Street Market at Crooked Can | Dojo Dumplings, among other vendors | Open since June 10 |
October Weekends on the Street
The fall calendar runs through these same blocks. For the Love of Hilliard, created to fill the gap left when Hilliardfest was canceled, went ahead on Sept. 12. Weather canceled all outdoor activities, so select businesses hosted vendors indoors and nothing took place at Hilliard's Station Park. Two more dates are on the calendar this month:
- Haunted Village & Museum, Friday, Oct. 16, 6 to 9 p.m. The Hilliard Historical Society's Historical Village & Museum at Weaver Park hosts costumed trick-or-treating and a craft. Admission is $5, and children 3 and under get in free.
- Old Hilliard Halloween Haunt, Saturday, Oct. 24, 9 to 11 a.m. Expect trick-or-treating at businesses along Main Street, plus live music, balloon twisting and a Haunted Hip Hop performance at Hilliard's Station Park.
Halloween Haunt morning takes you past most of the table above. Start with a cookie at 4045 Main, see whether Harvest has opened its doors at 3987, and stop by 4066 for coffee if the pop-up is still running that Saturday. The bank at 4056 still looks like a bank, and it will through at least this winter.
If you're tracking how Old Hilliard's buildings are changing hands and getting reworked, the team at Home With Hood & Neidenthal is happy to talk through what's happening on Main Street, address by address. Start Your Home Journey whenever you're ready.