What will a house in Lewis Center cost you in property taxes in 2027? This October, nobody can give you an exact figure. The county auditor can't, the seller can't, and neither can the number printed on the listing sheet. Delaware County's 2026 triennial valuation update has produced proposed market values only. The county says it can't calculate new tax amounts until the November election results and tax rates are certified, and it expects those amounts "mid-late December 2026."
The newest bill any seller can show you right now is for tax year 2025, which is being paid during 2026, and it was calculated before the 2026 update and the new credit schedule. Your first full bill will be for tax year 2026, payable in 2027. Four separate things will set it, and three of them are still moving: the certified value, the November 3 ballot, your own occupancy status and the school district's position relative to the state's 20-mill floor.
The Calendar a Buyer Is Actually Working Against
| Date | What happens |
|---|---|
| Now | Proposed 2026 values are posted and still under State of Ohio review |
| October 30, 2026 | Deadline for online informal review of proposed values |
| November 3, 2026 | Election day, with two countywide-area levies affecting Orange Township on the ballot |
| Mid-late December 2026 | Final certified values and new tax amounts expected |
| January 1 to March 31, 2027 | Window to file a formal valuation complaint on the 2026 update |
The Delaware County Auditor's 2026 update materials describe the proposed values as subject to change while the state reviews them. We haven't found any published countywide percentage change for the proposed 2026 residential values, either from the county or in local reporting. That means nobody can honestly tell you "values went up X percent" for Orange Township yet. A triennial update adjusts values using sales data and market conditions and doesn't involve a drive-by inspection.
The county also warns that a higher value doesn't automatically mean a matching tax increase. The auditor's update summary points to House Bill 920, a 1976 law that limits unvoted tax growth when values rise for school districts above the 20-mill floor. Whether that protection works the same way in Lewis Center depends on where Olentangy sits relative to that floor, which comes up below. First, there's a change that affects the bill no matter what the value turns out to be.
The Credit Follows the Occupant, Not the House
In December 2025, Governor DeWine signed five property tax bills, HB 124, HB 129, HB 186, HB 309 and HB 335, as Signal Ohio reported. The Ohio Legislature's page for HB 186 lists March 20, 2026 as the effective date.
HB 186 changes the two residential credits that reduce a tax bill. In a January 16, 2026 statement, Delaware County Auditor George Kaitsa laid out the schedule for county taxpayers:
- For tax year 2026 bills payable in 2027, the nonbusiness credit drops to 7.5%.
- In the same bills, the owner-occupancy credit rises from 2.5% to 5.7%.
- By tax year 2029, the owner-occupancy credit reaches 15.38% and the nonbusiness credit is gone, except on agricultural land.
Cleveland.com described the effect as moving the nonbusiness credit away from rental properties, including large corporate landlords, and toward homeowners who live in their homes.
That's why a listing's tax line works poorly as a forecast. Two buyers can close on the same Lewis Center house at the same price, one moving in and one renting it out, and starting with the 2026 tax year their bills begin to separate, a little more each year through 2029. Any bill the seller has received was figured under the credit rates in effect before tax year 2026, so it can't show where either buyer will land. An investor running numbers on a single-family rental here is looking at a credit that shrinks every year until 2029. An owner-occupant is looking at one that grows.
Why Olentangy's Position on the Floor Matters
The 20-mill floor is the minimum effective school operating rate. Districts sitting at it have historically seen taxes rise directly with values after a reappraisal. Districts above it get the HB 920 reduction factors, which scale voted levies back as values climb.
The new law adds an inflation cap for floor districts. Kaitsa's statement spells out who got the first round of that relief. For tax year 2025 bills payable in 2026, property owners in the Big Walnut, Buckeye Valley and Delaware City school districts receive an inflation tax credit. Owners in the Olentangy, Dublin and Westerville districts don't, "because those school districts were not at the 20-mill floor during the reappraisal in 2023."
For tax year 2026, the auditor says floor districts won't see increases beyond inflation from the triennial update. In every district, "voted levies will continue to be lowered by the tax reduction factor to offset the increases in property values." Separately, HB 335 caps growth in inside, unvoted millage during a reappraisal or update year at the sum of the three previous years of inflation, according to the Ohio House announcement of the signing.
For an Olentangy-district home, then, the main brake on value-driven increases is HB 920's reduction factors, which Ohio already had, plus the new inside-millage cap. The inflation-cap credit that floor districts get isn't part of it. One more change could shift which districts sit where. Under HB 129, emergency and substitute levies now count toward the 20-mill floor starting with the first qualifying update year from tax year 2026. Kaitsa expects "fewer school districts at the 20-mill floor" as a result.
What's Actually on the November 3 Ballot
If the reduction factors hold value-driven growth down, then in the auditor's words, "any increases in property taxes above the rate of inflation will be the result of levies passed by the voters in 2026." Orange Township voters will see two such items.
- Delaware County Board of Developmental Disabilities, 1.8 mills. The Powell-Olentangy Journal reported that the levy returns to the November 3 ballot, at an estimated $63 a year per $100,000 of market value, and that it serves Orange Township residents. On a home the auditor values at $500,000, that comes to about $315 a year if it passes.
- Delaware Area Career Center renewal, 0.75 mills. Delaware Source reported a reduced 10-year renewal, with the auditor estimating $18 a year per $100,000 of home value. Olentangy is one of the four career-technical planning districts whose residents vote on it. At a $500,000 auditor value, that's about $90 a year.
Olentangy Local Schools has no levy of its own on this ballot as far as our research found. The last one was in November 2025, when voters approved a $235 million bond by 56% in unofficial results, which The Columbus Dispatch reported. The district said the bond wouldn't raise the tax rate. The district's levy information page also says it anticipates an operating levy within two to three years. For anyone planning to stay in Lewis Center past 2027, that's the next known decision point on the school side of the bill. One option is gone, though. The auditor says replacement levies can no longer be placed on the ballot, so any future school operating request will appear as a renewal or a new levy.
Where the Market Sits While the Bill Gets Settled
None of this is happening in a frozen market. In August 2026, the Olentangy Local School District recorded 138 closed sales, up 12.2% from a year earlier. The median sale price was $590,000, up 2.6%, and the average was $647,520, up 5.4%, according to the Columbus REALTORS district report. Those figures cover the whole district, which reaches into both Delaware and Franklin counties, so they aren't a Lewis Center-only number.
The same August report shows homes in the district took 34 days to sell, up 25.9%, with 347 homes in inventory and 2.7 months of supply. Delaware County overall posted a $550,000 median in August 2026, up 4.8%, with 30 days on market and 2.4 months of supply.
Prices are still rising slowly while homes take longer to sell and supply edges up, and all of it is happening on the same calendar as the tax inputs. A contract signed this month can easily still be open on November 3. Depending on its timeline, it may close near the mid-late December date the auditor has set for certified values and new tax amounts.
A Few Questions That Come Up
Is the proposed value on the auditor's site my new value? Not yet. The county calls it proposed and subject to state review. Certified values are expected mid-late December 2026.
When is the next full reappraisal? Kaitsa's statement says Delaware County's next sexennial reappraisal moves to 2030 under the state's new schedule. The 2026 update is the last value reset before then.
Can a value be challenged after the December certification? The auditor's materials describe a formal valuation complaint window for the 2026 update from January 1 through March 31, 2027.
Does the credit change apply to farmland too? No. Agricultural land keeps the nonbusiness credit.
If you're weighing a Lewis Center home this fall, Home With Hood & Neidenthal can pull the parcel's proposed value, check which levies apply to it and line those up against your closing date, so the 2027 bill isn't a surprise. Start Your Home Journey with a conversation about the numbers behind the listing.
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.